The Jeep Renegade offers an affordable entry point into the Jeep family, combining compact dimensions with the brand’s signature off-road capability. However, not all model years deliver the reliability you’d expect. Before purchasing a used Renegade, it’s crucial to know which problematic years to avoid and which ones offer better dependability.
This comprehensive guide will help you navigate the Jeep Renegade’s history, highlighting the most troublesome model years and their common issues.
Jeep Renegade Years to Avoid
Based on extensive research from owner reports, NHTSA data, and Consumer Reports reliability ratings, these are the Jeep Renegade model years with the most significant problems:
The 2015-2018 Jeep Renegade models have the most reported issues and should be approached with caution
- 2015 Jeep Renegade
- 2016 Jeep Renegade
- 2017 Jeep Renegade
- 2018 Jeep Renegade
Don’t Buy A Lemon!
Before purchasing any used Jeep Renegade, get a comprehensive vehicle history report to uncover potential hidden problems, accident history, and service records.
2015 Jeep Renegade: The Worst Year
The inaugural 2015 Jeep Renegade earns the dubious distinction of being the most problematic year in the model’s history. As the first production year, it suffered from numerous “first-generation” issues that Jeep would attempt to address in subsequent models.
The 2015 Renegade frequently experiences check engine light issues at relatively low mileage
Major Problems with the 2015 Renegade:
Check Engine Light Issues
Many owners reported the check engine light activating around 21,000 miles with no apparent cause. While sometimes the light would extinguish on its own, this issue signals potential underlying problems that could cost approximately $1,640 to repair.
9-Speed Transmission Problems
The 2015 Renegade’s 9-speed automatic transmission is notoriously problematic, with owners reporting hard shifts, extended shift timing, jerking, hesitation, and general unresponsiveness—often occurring at surprisingly low mileage.
“The 2015 Jeep Renegade received the ‘Beware of the Clunker Award’ from Car Complaints due to the high number of issues reported for such a new model.”
2016 Jeep Renegade: Still Problematic
While the 2016 Renegade showed some improvements over the 2015 model, it still accumulated over 600 NHTSA complaints according to Car Complaints data. This model year continued to exhibit significant reliability concerns.
The 2016 Renegade often experiences traction control system activation issues during turns
Common Issues with the 2016 Renegade:
2016 Renegade Problems
- Traction Control Malfunctions: The traction control system would activate unexpectedly during turns, causing the vehicle to nearly stop completely—a serious safety concern occurring at an average of just 7,000 miles.
- Premium Audio System Failures: The optional $695 Beats audio system upgrade with 9 speakers and a 506-watt amplifier was widely reported to deliver poor sound quality that didn’t match its premium price.
- Electrical System Problems: Various electrical issues including malfunctioning displays and erratic sensor behavior were commonly reported.
2017 Jeep Renegade: Ongoing Reliability Issues
The 2017 Jeep Renegade continued the trend of reliability problems, accumulating over 700 complaints and triggering three recalls. This model year is particularly known for its engine and electrical system issues.
Engine stalling was a significant problem for the 2017 Renegade models
Major Problems with the 2017 Renegade:
Engine Problems
The 2017 Renegade’s engine was prone to stalling while driving without warning. Many owners also reported excessive oil consumption and knocking or rattling noises from the engine compartment.
Electrical System Failures
The instrument panel in the 2017 model was particularly problematic, with issues ranging from malfunctioning radios to spotty navigation systems and multiple indicator lights activating simultaneously.
Warning: The 2017 Jeep Renegade was subject to a recall for potential fuel pressure loss that could cause engine stalling in certain operating conditions, particularly at high altitude or in hot weather.
2018 Jeep Renegade: Improved But Still Flawed
While the 2018 Renegade showed some improvements over previous years, it still exhibited enough reliability issues to make our list of years to avoid. The problems were less widespread but still significant for owners.
Excessive oil consumption was a common complaint with 2018 Renegade models
Notable Issues with the 2018 Renegade:
- Excessive Oil Consumption: Many drivers reported their 2018 Renegades consuming oil at an alarming rate, with problems appearing around 16,000 miles on average.
- Clutch Failures: Though less common, there were reports of clutch plates disintegrating in the housing, rendering vehicles completely inoperable.
- Software Issues: Electronic glitches affecting various vehicle systems required software updates to resolve.
Common Problems Across All Problematic Jeep Renegade Years
While each model year has its specific issues, several problems are common across the 2015-2018 Jeep Renegade models. Understanding these recurring issues can help you make an informed decision when considering a used Renegade.
Common problems affecting the 2015-2018 Jeep Renegade models
| Problem Area | Specific Issue | Typical Mileage | Estimated Repair Cost |
| Engine | Excessive oil consumption (2.4L Tigershark) | 15,000-30,000 miles | $800-$2,500 |
| Transmission | Hard shifts, jerking, hesitation (9-speed automatic) | 10,000-40,000 miles | $1,500-$4,000 |
| Electrical System | Random vehicle shutoff, sensor malfunctions | Varies widely | $300-$1,200 |
| Emissions | Excessive emissions, failed tests | 20,000-50,000 miles | $400-$1,500 |
Protect Your Investment
Already own a Jeep Renegade or planning to purchase one? Get peace of mind with an extended warranty that covers these common issues.
Reliable Jeep Renegade Years to Consider
Not all Jeep Renegade model years should be avoided. If you’re set on purchasing this compact SUV, consider these more reliable model years that have shown fewer problems and better overall dependability.
The 2019 and newer Jeep Renegade models show significant reliability improvements
2019 Jeep Renegade
The 2019 model year marked a significant improvement in the Renegade’s reliability. While still not perfect, it addressed many of the issues that plagued earlier models.
Improvements:
- More reliable transmission performance
- Reduced oil consumption issues
- Better electrical system stability
Best Trims:
For the best value and reliability, focus on the Limited and Trailhawk trims, which offer better features and more refined performance than the base models.
2020 Jeep Renegade and Newer
By 2020, Jeep had addressed many of the Renegade’s earlier problems, earning it a J.D. Power Quality and Reliability score of 80 out of 100—a significant improvement over previous years.
The 2020 Renegade features improved interior quality and technology
The 2020-2023 models offer:
- More generous cabin space
- Improved ride quality
- Enhanced off-roading capability
- More reliable mechanical components
- Updated technology features
“The 2020 Renegade delivers a reliability rating of 80 out of 100 from J.D. Power for Quality and Reliability, showing Jeep’s commitment to addressing earlier issues.”
Find Reliable Jeep Renegade Models
Looking for a dependable Jeep Renegade? Get a personalized list of the most reliable models available in your area.
Reliable Alternatives to the Jeep Renegade
If you’re concerned about the Jeep Renegade’s reliability issues but still want a compact SUV with similar capabilities, consider these more dependable alternatives:
Reliable alternatives to the Jeep Renegade: Mazda CX-30, Honda CR-V, and Kia Soul
Mazda CX-30
Introduced in 2019, the Mazda CX-30 offers more interior space than the Renegade with excellent safety ratings and superior reliability. Available with all-wheel drive and efficient 4-cylinder engines.
Honda CR-V
The Honda CR-V has been in production since 1995 and has consistently improved in reliability and features. While slightly larger than the Renegade, it offers exceptional dependability, fuel efficiency, and more interior space.
Kia Soul
The Kia Soul offers a unique design with a spacious interior and powerful four-cylinder engine at an affordable price point. While it lacks the off-road capabilities of the Renegade, it provides superior reliability and technology features.
Tips for Buying a Used Jeep Renegade
If you’re still interested in purchasing a Jeep Renegade despite the potential issues with certain model years, follow these tips to ensure you make a smart purchase:
Always have a pre-purchase inspection performed by a qualified mechanic
1. Research the Vehicle History
Before purchasing any used Jeep Renegade, obtain a comprehensive vehicle history report using the VIN. Look for:
- Previous accidents or damage
- Service and maintenance records
- Number of previous owners
- Recall compliance history
- Title status (salvage, rebuilt, etc.)
2. Get a Pre-Purchase Inspection
Have a qualified mechanic familiar with Jeep vehicles perform a thorough inspection before purchase. They should specifically check:
- Transmission operation and fluid condition
- Engine oil level and condition
- Electrical system functionality
- Signs of excessive oil consumption
- Suspension and steering components
3. Test Drive Thoroughly
During your test drive, pay special attention to:
- Transmission behavior (shifts, hesitation, jerking)
- Engine performance (stalling, unusual noises)
- Electrical system operation (all lights, infotainment, etc.)
- Brake performance and feel
- Steering response and alignment
4. Verify Recall Compliance
Check if all applicable recalls have been addressed by:
- Visiting the NHTSA website and entering the VIN
- Contacting a Jeep dealership with the VIN
- Reviewing recall documentation in the vehicle history
5. Consider an Extended Warranty
Given the Renegade’s reliability issues, an extended warranty or vehicle service contract may provide valuable protection against unexpected repairs, especially for:
- Transmission components
- Engine and powertrain
- Electrical systems
- Electronic components
Be Prepared Before You Buy
Download our comprehensive pre-purchase inspection checklist specifically designed for used Jeep Renegade models.
Jeep Renegade: Bad Years vs. Good Years Comparison
To help you quickly identify which Jeep Renegade model years to consider and which to avoid, we’ve created this comparison table highlighting the key differences:
Visual comparison between problematic early models and more reliable later Jeep Renegade models
| Feature | Problematic Years (2015-2018) | Reliable Years (2019+) |
| Transmission Reliability | Poor – frequent shifting issues, jerking, hesitation | Improved – smoother operation, fewer complaints |
| Engine Performance | Problematic – stalling, excessive oil consumption | More reliable – fewer stalling reports, better oil management |
| Electrical System | Unreliable – random shutoffs, sensor malfunctions | More stable – fewer electrical gremlins |
| Recalls | Multiple major recalls affecting safety systems | Fewer recalls, less severe issues |
| J.D. Power Reliability Score | Below average (60-70/100) | Average to good (75-80/100) |
| Owner Satisfaction | Low – many complaints on forums and review sites | Higher – fewer reliability complaints |
Conclusion: Making an Informed Jeep Renegade Purchase
The Jeep Renegade offers a unique combination of compact dimensions, distinctive styling, and off-road capability that many buyers find appealing. However, as our research shows, not all model years deliver the same reliability and ownership experience.
Choosing a reliable Jeep Renegade model year can lead to a more satisfying ownership experience
To summarize our findings:
Jeep Renegade Years to Avoid: 2015, 2016, 2017, and 2018 model years have demonstrated significant reliability issues with transmission, engine, and electrical systems.
Jeep Renegade Years to Consider: 2019 and newer models show marked improvements in reliability and overall quality, with the 2020 model earning a respectable 80/100 reliability score from J.D. Power.
If you’re set on purchasing a Jeep Renegade, we recommend:
- Focusing your search on 2019 and newer models
- Considering the Limited or Trailhawk trims for the best value and features
- Always getting a pre-purchase inspection from a qualified mechanic
- Obtaining a comprehensive vehicle history report
- Test driving thoroughly to check for any signs of the common issues we’ve outlined
By following these guidelines and avoiding the problematic model years, you can enjoy the unique character and capabilities of the Jeep Renegade while minimizing the risk of expensive repairs and reliability headaches.
